The World of Sharks Podcast
Podcast

From Shark Brains to Fish n’ Chips: The Full Spectrum of Shark Science

SHOW NOTES

From understanding how pollutants are passed from mother sharks to their offspring, to exploring the extraordinary evolution of shark brains and uncovering the hidden sharks in our favourite dishes, Dr Chris Mull – Adjunct Professor at Dalhousie University – has spent his career asking all sorts of questions about sharks and rays. In this episode get ready to discover just how much there is to learn about these remarkable animals – and why the answers matter for their conservation.

We begin with a rather extraordinary underwater encounter [05.55]. Growing up in Hermosa Beach in Southern California, Chris spent much of his childhood surfing, swimming and diving. The ocean was his happy place, and it was here that he first developed his fascination with sharks. But one experience in particular has stayed with him. While diving for lobsters at night off Palos Verdes, Chris suddenly felt something brushing against the top of his head –  which, when you’re underwater, is not necessarily a welcome sensation! Looking up, he discovered an enormous angel shark, around five and a half feet long, passing directly overhead. Chris compares the moment to the opening of Star Wars, with a huge spaceship gliding above him. The shark then circled around to investigate his bag of lobsters before eventually disappearing into the darkness. Despite spending much of his life in the ocean, Chris has never encountered another angel shark in the wild. It’s a memory that perfectly captures the excitement and unpredictability of studying marine life.

Chris’s fascination with sharks began remarkably early [08.25]. According to his parents, he announced at just three or four years old that he wanted to work with sharks when he grew up. And unlike many childhood dreams, this one came true. Later, studying for his master’s degree at California State University Long Beach, Chris worked with shark scientist Chris Lowe and learned a philosophy that would shape the rest of his career: the more skills you have, the more scientific questions you can answer. As Chris explains, it’s about building a “tool belt” of research skills. Rather than specialising in one technique or subject, he wanted to learn as much as possible about the different ways scientists could investigate sharks.

One of those tools was analytical chemistry, which led Chris into the world of shark toxicology [09.15]. Working at a chemical analysis facility in Southern California, he became interested in the pollutants accumulating in marine animals. The region has a long history of industrial and urban pollution, making it an important place to investigate how contaminants move through marine food webs. Chris and his colleagues began analysing tissue samples from juvenile white sharks that had died after being accidentally caught in fisheries. They discovered high concentrations of contaminants, including mercury, PCBs and DDT-related chemicals. But the most surprising finding was that some of these animals were so young that they couldn’t possibly have accumulated such high levels through feeding alone. Instead, the researchers found evidence of maternal offloading – the transfer of contaminants from a mother shark to her developing offspring. Sharks often invest considerable energy in reproduction, and during pregnancy mothers mobilise nutrients stored in their bodies to nourish their young. Unfortunately, certain pollutants can be stored alongside those nutrients, particularly in fatty tissues such as the liver. When those energy reserves are mobilised, contaminants can also be transferred to the embryos. Chris explains that some juvenile white sharks contained concentrations of pollutants far beyond what they could have accumulated during their first few weeks or months of life. The most likely explanation was that they had inherited them from their mothers before birth. Understanding the effect of such pollution – inherited before a shark can even explore the underwater world – is an important scientific challenge, particularly for species that already face considerable pressure from fishing. For Chris, the project also demonstrated how techniques from chemistry could reveal something entirely new about shark biology.

From toxic chemicals, we move into a completely different area of research: the evolution of shark brains [12.44]. Chris’s desire to learn new skills eventually led him to undertake a PhD with shark scientists Nick Dulvy and Kara Yopak, investigating how and why the brains of sharks and rays have evolved. One of the central questions Chris wanted to explore was why some animals evolve larger brains than others. Having a large brain can offer important advantages, including greater behavioural flexibility and the ability to process complex information. But brains are also incredibly expensive organs to maintain – neurological tissue can require around 20 times more energy than skeletal muscle. A larger brain must provide enough benefits to justify its considerable energetic cost. Previous studies of birds and mammals had suggested that larger brains were often associated with slower life histories, including longer lifespans, later maturity and greater investment in fewer offspring. Chris wanted to know whether the same patterns occurred in sharks and rays.

His research revealed a fascinating connection between maternal investment and brain size and complexity [16.12]. Some sharks and rays provide developing embryos with additional nourishment beyond their initial yolk supply. This can take several forms, including placental connections, nutrient-rich uterine secretions and even unfertilised eggs produced for embryos to consume. Chris found that species with these additional forms of maternal nourishment tended to have brains approximately 20–70% larger than those of species that utilised other methods. This suggests that investing more energy in offspring during development may give their brains something of a “head start”. Chris also explains that the evolution of these reproductive strategies occurred alongside changes in habitat use, behaviour and brain organisation. As sharks and rays spread into new environments, their bodies, brains and life histories evolved together.

But what about the basking shark, an enormous animal with a famously small brain relative to its body size [17.57]? Chris explains that brain size doesn’t increase at the same rate as body size. As animals become larger, their brains generally become proportionally smaller; because brains are energetically expensive, there is little advantage in maintaining more neurological tissue than an animal needs. Basking sharks also have additional energetic demands, including the ability to maintain elevated temperatures in certain parts of their bodies. But Chris is quick to point out that having a relatively small brain doesn’t mean basking sharks are simple animals. In fact, their brains reveal some remarkably sophisticated adaptations – a highly developed cerebellum, associated with movement and motor control, as well as a relatively large telencephalon, or forebrain, which may play an important role in spatial memory. These allow basking sharks to excel at finding dense aggregations of plankton in the vast expanse of the open ocean, tracking features like ocean fronts, and remember these productive areas for next time. “Basking sharks have brains that are designed to be a basking shark,” Chris says.

After that extraordinary detour, Isla and Chris finally arrive at the subject that originally inspired the episode: the global shark meat trade [25.11]. Chris became involved in the Shark Meat Project partly because he wanted to develop new quantitative research skills, but also because he was increasingly interested in applying scientific research to conservation and fisheries management. For decades, much of the attention surrounding shark exploitation has focused on the international trade in shark fins. While this research has been enormously important, Chris explains that another major market has received comparatively little attention: shark and ray meat. And as the global trade in fins has declined, the trade in meat has been increasing.

Understanding this trade is particularly complicated because it is spread across so many countries and cultures [26.30]. Unlike shark fins, which have historically been associated with relatively concentrated markets, shark and ray meat is consumed across South America, Southeast Asia, Africa, Europe and Australia. Different countries also have very different preferences. South Korea, for example, is a major importer of skates and rays, particularly for a traditional fermented skate dish called hongeo-hoe. European countries, including France and the United Kingdom, also consume considerable quantities of sharks and rays. Chris explains that shark meat isn’t necessarily a secondary product of fishing anymore. In some places, its increasing value means sharks are being deliberately targeted rather than caught incidentally.

The scale of this trade is staggering [28.01]. Chris explains that research continues to support estimates of around 100 million sharks being caught annually, despite decades of conservation efforts. His team’s work has also suggested that close to 200 million rays may be landed each year, revealing a level of exploitation that has received far less public attention. In some countries, changes in fishing pressure have also shifted catches from sharks towards rays.

Which brings us to a rather surprising question: could there be shark in your fish and chips? [30.03]. In many parts of the world, people consume shark meat without necessarily realising what it is. In Brazil, for example, shark is commonly marketed as cação, while in the United Kingdom it may appear under names such as rock salmon, huss or flake. These names can make it difficult for consumers to know exactly which animal they’re eating. Chris explains that fish and chips have traditionally been associated with a relatively small number of shark species, including spiny dogfish in the UK and gummy sharks and school sharks in Australia. Their flesh is pale, mild-flavoured and cooks in a similar way to familiar white fish such as cod and haddock, making it relatively easy to substitute one for another.

But the story becomes even more complicated when we consider where those sharks are coming from [31.18]. A species may be relatively well managed in one country but severely depleted elsewhere, and because seafood is traded internationally, the shark served in a local fish and chip shop may have travelled a surprisingly long distance before reaching the plate. Chris and his colleagues are investigating this problem through a research initiative called Baited Switch. The project examines how international seafood trade can transfer the environmental costs of fishing from one country to another. Australia, for example, has invested considerable effort in managing its domestic shark fisheries, but a large proportion of the seafood consumed there is imported with some of the sharks used for fish and chips coming from New Zealand and other countries. The UK also imports spiny dogfish from fisheries in North America and Europe.

“I always thought biology was hard…and then I started dealing with human stuff,” he laughs.

So what can consumers do if they want to avoid accidentally eating shark [37.00]? Chris recommends looking for seafood that is clearly labelled at the species level, rather than relying on vague marketing names. Buying from fishmongers or suppliers who know where their fish comes from can also help. Locally sourced seafood may offer greater traceability, although local doesn’t automatically mean sustainable. And importantly, even products marketed under familiar names may not always contain the species consumers expect. Research in the UK and Australia has identified a surprisingly wide range of sharks and rays in fish and chips, including species subject to conservation regulations. Once an animal has been processed into a fillet, identifying it becomes extremely difficult.

After exploring the complicated world of seafood trade, Isla and Chris turn to another of his projects: Sharkipedia, an open-access database designed to make scientific information about sharks, rays and chimaeras available to everyone [48.57]. Anyone can register, download information and contribute published data, with guidance available to help them through the process. Perhaps most excitingly, Sharkipedia is already helping bridge the gap between scientific research and conservation policy [54.04]. Chris explains that its data can be used to support electronic non-detriment findings, or eNDFs, which help countries assess whether international trade in CITES-listed species can take place without harming wild populations. Traditionally, the information used to justify these decisions has not always been standardised or publicly accessible. By connecting Sharkipedia to the eNDF process, researchers and conservation practitioners can access relevant biological and population data more easily. The same information could also support IUCN Red List assessments and other conservation decisions.

So, after the myriad of topics covered in this episode, what is Chris’ one take-home message? [58.09]. “One of the things that’s emerged in my career over the last ten years is that there’s a really unheralded amount of diversity in sharks and rays, that certainly the general public overlooks, but even a lot of times scientists do as well,” he says. “There’s a lot of analogy, homology, and things that make them a really good group for asking a lot of these questions.

There’s a lot of stuff that we are overlooking…but we shouldn’t.”

ABOUT OUR GUEST

Dr Chris Mull

Adjunct Professor, Dalhousie University

Chris was born and raised in Hermosa Beach, California. Growing up he saw leopard sharks, bat rays, and shovelnose guitarfish while swimming and surfing and decided at about three years old that he wanted to work on sharks. Chris did his undergraduate at UC Davis where he got to do his first independent research on leopard shark metabolic rate with Dr. Joe Cech. This led to a master’s at Cal State Long Beach with Chris Lowe, and finally a PhD with Nick Dulvy and Kara Yopak.

Along the way, Chris has tried to learn as many skills as possible and has worked on everything from reproductive physiology to brain evolution, and now focuses on conservation biology and fisheries and trade.

Key links and sources:

Sharkipedia database

Meat trade project

All publications

Image